The most common commercial auto gap I find isn't at businesses that have company vehicles and no commercial policy. It's at businesses where employees regularly drive their own vehicles for work, and the owner assumes that's covered somewhere — probably the employee's personal auto policy, or maybe the company's GL.
It's covered by neither. Personal auto policies exclude business use. General liability doesn't cover auto accidents. And when one of those employees has a serious accident on the way to a client meeting, both the employee and the business owner find out simultaneously that no policy applies.
Why Personal Auto Doesn't Cover Business Use
Personal auto insurance is written for personal use — commuting, errands, personal travel. The policy language in virtually every personal auto policy excludes use for business purposes. This isn't a technicality carriers invoke reluctantly. It's a standard exclusion they enforce consistently.
What counts as business use? Driving to a client site, making a delivery for the company, transporting materials or equipment, running errands for the business. It doesn't matter whose vehicle it is — the employee's, the owner's, or one the company borrowed. If the purpose of the trip is business, personal auto doesn't apply.
And it doesn't matter how rarely it happens. An employee who drives to one client meeting per week and has an accident on that drive has a business-use problem, not a personal-use claim.
The Scenario Most Owners Miss
A small Chaska-area service company has three employees who drive their own vehicles to client sites daily. The owner has never thought about commercial auto — nobody owns a company truck, so the question never came up. One employee has a serious accident on 494 during a client visit. The injured party has $180,000 in medical bills and lost wages. The employee's personal auto insurer reviews the claim, confirms it was a business trip, and denies coverage. The injured party's attorney sends a demand letter to the business.
The business has no commercial auto policy. The GL policy excludes auto accidents. The owner is looking at a $180,000 exposure with no policy to respond to it.
Hired and non-owned auto (HNOA) coverage would have covered exactly this situation — and it typically costs a few hundred dollars a year added to a GL or BOP policy.
The question every business owner should answer: Do any of your employees — or do you yourself — drive to client sites, make deliveries, or use a vehicle for any business purpose? If yes, and you don't have commercial auto or HNOA coverage, you have an uninsured gap.
Hired and Non-Owned Auto (HNOA) — The Often-Missing Piece
HNOA coverage has two components:
- Non-owned auto — covers your business's liability when employees use their personal vehicles for work purposes. It doesn't cover damage to the employee's car — that's their problem. It covers claims made against your business when their accident causes injury or property damage to a third party.
- Hired auto — covers your business's liability when you rent or borrow a vehicle for business use. Renting a van for a trade show, borrowing a trailer, using a rental car for a business trip.
HNOA can usually be added as an endorsement to your general liability or business owners policy for a modest additional premium — often $200–$500/year depending on your employee count and how much driving is involved. It's not a full commercial auto policy. It covers liability only, not physical damage to vehicles your employees or the business owns.
When You Need a Full Commercial Auto Policy
HNOA covers the liability exposure when employees use their own vehicles. But if your business owns vehicles — trucks, vans, service vehicles, delivery vehicles — you need a commercial auto policy. The vehicle titled to the business needs commercial coverage, full stop.
A commercial auto policy covers:
- Liability — bodily injury and property damage you cause to others (required by law)
- Collision — damage to your vehicle in an accident, regardless of fault
- Comprehensive — theft, hail, fire, and other non-collision losses
- Uninsured/underinsured motorist — when another driver causes damage and has inadequate coverage
- Medical payments — for you and your employees after an accident
| Situation | Right coverage |
|---|---|
| Employees drive their own cars to client sites | HNOA endorsement |
| Business rents vehicles for work trips | HNOA endorsement |
| Business owns one or more vehicles | Commercial auto policy |
| Owner drives personal car occasionally for work | HNOA at minimum |
| Vehicles used to haul cargo or equipment | Commercial auto + possibly cargo coverage |
| Covered by personal auto only | Gap — business use excluded |
What Commercial Auto Costs in Minnesota
Commercial auto premiums depend on vehicle type, use, driver records, coverage limits, and how many vehicles are on the policy. Rough ranges:
- HNOA endorsement on a GL or BOP: $200–$500/year (covers employee-owned vehicle liability only)
- One passenger vehicle / light truck (commercial policy): $1,200–$2,400/year
- Service or work van: $1,500–$3,000/year
- Multi-vehicle fleets: Varies significantly — fleet rates often better per vehicle than individual policies
For most small businesses where employees drive their own vehicles, HNOA is the most cost-effective solution. For businesses with company-owned vehicles, a commercial auto policy is required — the only question is how to structure it and what limits make sense.
Tom Wertish
President & AgentTom founded Options Insurance in 2014 and works with businesses across the Twin Cities metro on commercial auto, HNOA coverage, and the gaps that don't show up until a claim happens. If you have employees driving to client sites and you're not sure whether your program covers that exposure, that's a fifteen-minute conversation worth having.
Contractor? The personal vehicle gap is even more common in the trades. Here's the full contractor insurance checklist.
What Commercial Insurance Does a Contractor Need in Minnesota? →